I know the advice is to test the mat that works for you, but everything around here is much more expensive, so I’m relying on my fellow yogis for the best yoga mats on Amazon. I’m at your mercy!
My partner and I need the extra-long versions for our home practice. Most stores either have them sealed in plastic or don’t carry the brands I’m interested in like B-Mat or Manduka’s eco-friendly lines.
And I know some people don’t like Amazon but they have everything andworst case I can order a few mats and return the ones I don’t like. Local yoga studios sometimes let you try different mats during classes, but we practice at home, so that’s not really an option for us. I’m particularly curious about those who’ve ordered from Amazon or other online retailers and how the return process went if the mat didn’t work out. It seems crazy that for something so personal where grip and feel matter so much, we’re expected to buy blind based on online reviews alone.
17 Likes
Deepen Your Practice Beyond the Mat
Finding meaningful yoga discussions and guidance can be surprisingly difficult. Discover a space where your questions are welcomed and your growth is celebrated: Start Your Journey
Personally I don’t really bother testing a mat because they always change after a little breaking in anyway. So the mat you test in the store is not the mat you’ll be using really. All of my best mats have come online.
Region changes might differ but if you take a look at the yoga mat master list, a lot of them are available on Amazon so you’ll probably find what you need.
Hope that helps!
Amazon’s return window saved me when I ordered a TPE mat that smelled like a tire factory for weeks.
The Retrospec Solana is secretly amazing for $35, basically a Manduka dupe with decent grip. Just rolled up my 84 version after morning practice, and it fits perfectly in my closet without that annoying curl some cheaper mats get.
Mat spray recipe = water + witch hazel + lavender oil.
Have you considered the Jade Harmony XL? Has anyone actually tested their claim about natural rubber being grippier when wet? And what about those cork mats? Do they really stay “antimicrobial” or is that just marketing?
OH! And since we’re on the topic, has anyone successfully returned a used mat to Amazon after a sweaty practice session? That seems… weird.
Well, actually, I’d suggest going with YogaOutlet or Manduka directly, their return policies are surprisingly generous for activewear and equipment compared to Amazon (in my experience of returns anyway).
If I need to get something vital like a yoga mat for my practice, I’ll typically order 3 or 4 different thicknesses and textures to test on various surfaces, then return the ones that don’t provide the right grip or cushioning for my knees.
Mat thickness varies wildly when browsing, the Retrospec Solana at 25mm versus the Elina Classical at 100mm is a massive difference that completely changes your practice stability.
I find the thicker mats are amazing for restorative poses, but can actually make balancing poses harder because you sink into them.
I find the one from the supermarket with a towel on it does the trick just fine.
Can we talk about how ridiculous yoga mat prices have gotten? I saw one for $150 the other day, ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY DOLLARS for what is basically a rectangle of rubber! They had the audacity to call it an ‘alignment system’ with sacred geometry patterns. Listen, my body doesn’t suddenly know how to do crow pose better because there’s a mandala printed under my hands. The yoga industry really wants us to believe we need moisture-wicking, antimicrobial, eco-harvested mats blessed by Himalayan monks to achieve inner peace.
Meanwhile, yogis have been practicing for thousands of years on animal skins, bare ground, and probably whatever flat surface they could find. My $12 supermarket special with a beach towel on top has survived 5 years of daily practice and counting. Still does the job perfectly.
As someone who’s practiced for over a decade, more experienced yogis often appreciate the subtleties of mat texture and grip, while beginners might prioritize cushioning. Your needs evolve with your practice, so don’t be afraid to revisit your mat choice as you grow.
Oh, I know it might sound like the obvious choice, but honestly? places hands on heart My Lululemon mat has been an absolute breakthrough for my practice.
The grip is just unreal, even in the sweatiest hot yoga sessions, I stay completely planted. No sliding around in downward dog! The durability is incredible, too. My first one? Still thriving after a decade, it lives at my office now for lunchtime flows.
That’s actually why I treated myself to a second one for home practice. Pretty sure they make extended lengths if you need extra space for savasana! gently touches mat I went with their reversible option, though confession time, I’m totally devoted to the rubber side. It’s just perfection. Plus, can we talk about how gorgeous these mats are? Mine brings such good energy to my practice space! 
Has anyone else who’s over 6 feet tall found that the standard 71’ mats leave your hands or feet hanging off during poses like downward dog or savasana? And why do manufacturers call both 6mm and 5/8 inch mats ‘extra thick’ when there’s actually a noticeable difference in cushioning between them?
Spoiler alert: thickness matters WAY more than brand! Got a 4mm Gaiam for travel 
Liforme all the way! My Manduka’s solid too, but for indoor flows? Liforme’s grip during sweaty hot yoga is unmatched. Those alignment markers are a real difference, and it held up beautifully over the years. Definitely splurge, worthy, plus they make an XL version if your husband needs extra mat real estate.
When you’re flowing through your practice, especially in poses like Downward Facing Dog or Warrior II, that sleek, looking mat with the ultra, smooth surface can quickly turn into a slip hazard once you start building heat.
As you change from Chaturanga to Cobra, or hold those challenging balancing poses like Tree or Half Moon, you’ll want a foundation with texture and grip beneath you. Check those product descriptions for words like ‘textured,’ ‘non, slip’ or ‘grippy’, your wrists will thank you during those longer holds in Plank, and you’ll feel more confident dropping into Pigeon or attempting that first Crow pose.
After going through way too many mats myself (seriously, my closet looked like a yoga studio clearance sale at one point), what worked amazingly for my friend’s hot yoga practice felt completely wrong for my slower yin sessions.It’s such a personal journey finding your perfect mat!
The return process through Amazon was actually pretty painless when I ordered three different Manduka styles and sent back two, though I felt a bit guilty about the environmental impact of all that shipping. Sometimes I think we overthink it - my most changing practices have happened on borrowed mats or even hotel towels when traveling, reminding me it’s really about showing up, not the perfect gear.
Speaking of extra-long mats, I recently stumbled across this comparison where someone tested the grip on different Manduka PRO mats after sweating on them (kind of like a yoga version of Hot Ones but with downward dogs instead of wing sauce) and it really showed how the 85’ versions handle moisture differently than standard lengths, which might help narrow down your Amazon cart since you’re looking at those eco-friendly lines.
Just discovered that Manduka actually offers a 30-day satisfaction guarantee which reminds me of how B.K.S. Iyengar used to practice on simple cotton rugs before yoga mats were even invented in the 1960s - imagine trying to return those to a merchant!
My husband and I share a mat too (we practice at different times) and found that REI’s generous one-year return policy is amazing for testing, though they frustratingly don’t carry the extra-long versions you’re looking for. For what it’s worth, we ended up ordering through Amazon since they accept returns on yoga mats even if you’ve actually practiced on them, unlike B-Mat, which requires the mat to stay sealed in its original packaging.
Insider tip: If you’re ordering from Amazon, check the Q&A section on the product page. Often, real users will post photos and feedback on the mat’s performance in different environments, like carpeted floors versus hard surfaces. Why rely on stock photos when you can see how the product actually performs in real homes?
